Research shows that a staggering 87% of people using chatbots for emotional support have already been in therapy. That's 87% who sought help, found it didn't work for them, and turned to a chatbot as the next step rather than trying another professional – whether that be a sleep or meditation expert, or a well-being practitioner specializing in managing burnout, stress, or familial conflict, for example.
Let me be completely clear: that doesn't mean a wellness professional would have been the right fit in all of those cases, and it shouldn't be seen as a replacement for clinical help. But it does indicate that, where wellness support might have been useful, people are opting for an AI assistant over a proper, human professional.
Stigma is steering people towards chatbots
Some will bristle at the mention of this type of support, which has been undermined and delegitimized time and time again. While there is limited data on public perception of the wellness industry, one UK study illuminates these attitudes clearly. Just 42% said they'd trust these professionals, even if they held relevant qualifications.
That's a problem, because, at the same time, over a quarter of Americans now use AI chatbots for personal, emotional or social queries. A study published by JAMA Pediatrics echoes this trend, showing that 1 in 5 young people have turned to an LLM for advice when feeling angry, nervous, or stressed.
The statistics make it abundantly clear that our reticence to treat wellness as a "real" way of supporting people is pushing people toward AI. We've made people so embarrassed to call on this sector that they're turning to a far more dangerous option. That's something we have to fix.
Wellness is part of mental health
Because while it's absolutely true that emotional and social support, as well as health, career, stress-management, and nutritional advice, is very different from clinical psychology or therapy, it does make up a significant piece of the broader mental health puzzle. If you're interested in mental health, you should be interested in mental wellness, too.
Many of the challenges people need support for aren't necessarily clinical problems. And, even more importantly in my view, wellness practitioners' work plays a vital role in preventing more serious mental health issues that require clinical intervention.
We've made people so embarrassed to call on this sector that they're turning to a far more dangerous option.
A study by the CDC, for example, found that adults reporting loneliness or a lack of social and emotional support were almost twice as likely to suffer from depression. And the work of Danish researchers backs that up. They found that moderate mental well-being reduced the risk of common mental disorders by 55-68%, while high mental well-being brought it down by 69-90%. This work is clearly a core component of the broader mental health space – and it needs to be viewed as such if we're going to stop people from leaning too heavily on chatbots.
Why overreliance on AI is risky
Why is overreliance on AI a problem? First, because there is a complete lack of peer review in AI coaching. Responses go unchecked and unchallenged, with no external monitoring or assessment. The National Board for Health & Wellness Coaching's code of ethics says that certified coaches should "engage in supervision or peer review processes and support to maintain accountability and receive constructive feedback." There's none of that in place across AI.
Second, chatbots are notorious for agreeing with the person they are speaking to, even in situations where there is a clear need for ideas and thought patterns to be challenged. Stanford computer scientists found that across 11 models, AI affirmed users' actions 49% more often than humans on average, even in cases involving deception and illegality. No one can argue that dark support, which fails to push back against individuals where necessary, is a better option than a peer-reviewed, experienced wellness professional.
Two fixes to restore the sector's standing
It's clear we need a major narrative and attitude shift toward this space. And to encourage that, I'd argue we're in need of two core fixes.
To start, we need more wellness professionals. We need to expand career pathways with internships and training grants in order to encourage people to consider these jobs as valuable options. Creating online communities or forums for sharing ideas would also help to strengthen the industry and improve connectivity.
Then we need to improve the systems used by wellness professionals on a day-to-day basis, including the technology they depend on. A better technology backbone will reduce the time spent on administrative tasks, help them offer more flexible appointments, and offer stronger, more personalized resources. By bolstering the overall sector, my hope is that we can restore some of the respect that's been missing for so long.
There's a lot of work to do here, given this space has been undermined and overlooked for so long. Limited investment and effort have gone into supporting this sector, and that has to change if we're to move people away from AI.
Mental wellness goes hand in hand with mental health and mental illness, and we have to start treating it as the important part of the puzzle that it is. AI cannot, and should not, be allowed to fill that gap any longer. As it develops, so too do the risks associated with it, and if you don't want to see those risks develop into damaging consequences, you have to start treating wellness as the credible, valuable sector that it is.
Keep reading. It's free
- Wellness is part of mental health
- Why overreliance on AI is risky
- Two fixes to restore the sector's standing
3 more minutes to read.
Free. No spam, ever. One click to unsubscribe.
