The Wellness EditIssue 2, 29 Oct 2026All issues →

The wellness sector is the answer to dark support

More people are confiding in AI chatbots. Alexandra Tracy argues that accountable wellness practitioners, not unregulated AI, should fill that support gap.

Have you ever had a challenging day or something on your mind you can't quite shake? You look left, you look right, you're not sure who to talk to, so you look down at your phone and open ChatGPT. If that sounds like you, you're not alone.

Statistics show that across the United States, more individuals are turning to chatbots for the support they used to seek from other people.

Since the introduction of generative AI, there has been a rise in people, especially younger people, confiding in genAI as a pillar in their social and emotional support system. In fact, the APA's 2026 Chatbots and Mental Health Survey shows that 77% of psychologists in the United States have spoken with patients who have leaned on AI for support.

The risks of dark support

Seeking the emotional or social support dished out by an AI chatbot, "dark support," as we will call it, isn't inherently wrong. But it does open users up to major risks: the advice is unregulated and off the record, it tends to affirm users' thought processes rather than encourage different viewpoints, and, critically, it keeps any professional out of the loop.

Beyond that, it also reveals a symptom of a much deeper systemic support gap. One that fields like therapy or medicine are not filling.

In most cases, the biggest issue with dark support is the lack of a human reviewer. That is where the wellness system is needed.

Nikhil, Pathara co-founder and myself

Wellness practitioners or coaches have the knowledge and expertise to fill this support gap and help individuals take a holistic approach to care based on what they actually need.

Accountability that AI cannot offer

In every field that works with people's inner lives, there must be a system of external accountability that binds a practitioner to professional standards, peer review, and legal accountability. For Health and Wellness Coaching, that is the National Board for Health and Wellness Coaching (NBHWC), which enforces a strict Code of Ethics for every practitioner in the United States.

AI doesn't have a governing board. It does have technical guardrails set by a developer, and while they can prevent some forms of harm, they lack the empathy and ethical accountability of a human practitioner. Additionally, we have very little oversight of these interactions. We don't know whether the user is getting the right kind of help, and no one can step in if something begins to go wrong.

A support gap, not a treatment gap

To be clear, this is about a support gap, not a treatment gap. Clinical care must stay with the correct healthcare professionals. What I am talking about is day-to-day general health and well-being. More people than ever are reaching out to chatbots for social, emotional, or career support and might just need an impartial, experienced human to talk to.

That's where a coach, a wellness practitioner, or a holistic health specialist is most valuable.

Wellness practitioners are trained in prevention and holistic care based on what the individual needs, but more importantly, they bring the code of ethics and accountability AI alone lacks.

This is about a support gap, not a treatment gap.
Alexandra Tracy

Where AI fits in wellness care

I want to be clear that I'm not saying AI doesn't have a place in the wellness economy.

In fact, AI has already proven its worth within the wellness space by allowing support to continue after the appointment ends. Things like AI-supported habit tracking, check-ins, courses, resources, and more keep the client-practitioner relationship strong between sessions. Professionals using AI responsibly, with oversight, can streamline care and provide continuity, so clients are less likely to return to chatbots.

The key difference is that, unlike dark support, a practitioner stays in the loop and is accountable for everything the client receives.

At its core, the wellness sector is about prevention. The simple fact that people are seeking out dark support shows a demand for a more proactive, holistic style of support that complements clinical care by bridging the gap it can't fill.

The wellness sector has never been so well positioned to step up to the task. The job now is to make sure the world knows that we are here.

Keep reading. It's free

Still to come in this issue

  • Accountability that AI cannot offer
  • A support gap, not a treatment gap
  • Where AI fits in wellness care

2 more minutes to read.

Free. No spam, ever. One click to unsubscribe.

Questions this issue answers

What is dark support?

Alexandra Tracy uses "dark support" to describe emotional or social support sought from an AI chatbot. She says it isn't inherently wrong, but the advice is unregulated and off the record, tends to affirm users' thinking, and keeps any professional out of the loop.

Why are wellness practitioners better placed than AI chatbots to offer everyday support?

Alexandra Tracy argues that wellness practitioners are trained in prevention and holistic care, and are bound by a code of ethics and external accountability. In the United States, Health and Wellness Coaches are held to a Code of Ethics enforced by the NBHWC, whereas AI has no governing board.

Does AI have a role in wellness care?

Yes, according to Alexandra Tracy. AI-supported habit tracking, check-ins, courses and resources can keep the client-practitioner relationship strong between sessions. The key difference from dark support is that a practitioner stays in the loop and is accountable for what the client receives.

Written by

Alexandra Tracy

CEO and co-founder, Pathara. Dallas, Texas

Alexandra Tracy on where the wellness economy is heading, and who gets to build in it.

Roughly monthly. Unsubscribe any time.

Contact

For press, speaking or podcasts with Alexandra.